Description: This paper points out errors in the Graetz Prepayment Analysis used to determine tax liability for mutual companies. Those errors result in an understatement of the tax burden borne by mutual life insurance companies. The Graetz prepayment analysis was advanced as a justification for repealing Section 809 of the Internal Revenue Code. Correcting the errors in the Graetz prepayment analysis strengthens the argument for repeal.

Description: This is a discussion of the paper, Actuarial Note: Valuation of Reversionary Interests Involving Two or More Lives for Federal Tax Purposes by Charles G. Groeschell and William M. Snell. From Transactions of Society of Actuaries 1951, Vol. 3, No. 7.